Skip to content
๐ŸŒŸ Save Up to 75% on Weekly Deals! ๐ŸŒŸ Discover amazing savings on our Weekly Deals collection, including TATCHA products at up to 75% off. Enjoy free shipping on orders over $25! Shop now at our Weekly Deals page.
๐ŸŒŸ Up to 75% Off Weekly Deals! ๐ŸŒŸ Enjoy incredible discounts on our Weekly Deals collection, featuring TATCHA and more at up to 75% off. Free shipping on $25+ orders. Visit our Weekly Deals page now.

Sandwich Spreads

Elevate your sandwiches with the delicious and diverse sandwich spreads Collection at Discount Pantry. Our curated selection features a variety of high-quality spreads, including classic mayonnaise, tangy mustards, creamy aiolis, and unique gourmet blends. Each spread is crafted to enhance the flavor and texture of your favorite sandwiches, wraps, and snacks. Perfect for adding a burst of flavor and making your meals more enjoyable, our spreads are a must-have in any kitchen. Explore our ever-changing assortment and discover the perfect spread to complement your culinary creations at Discount Pantry.

Filters

$
$
  • Original price $88.83 - Original price $88.83
    Original price
    $88.83
    $88.83 - $88.83
    Current price $88.83

    Haddar - Tahini Seasoned - Case Of 12 - 15.9 Oz

    Haddar
    Only 13 left!

    Haddar - tahini seasoned - case of 12 - 15.9 ozcountry of origin : united statesis gluten free : yesis gmo free : yesis kosher : yessize : 15.9 o...

    View full details
    Original price $88.83 - Original price $88.83
    Original price
    $88.83
    $88.83 - $88.83
    Current price $88.83
  • Original price $114.59 - Original price $114.59
    Original price
    $114.59
    $114.59 - $114.59
    Current price $114.59

    Spectrum Naturals Mayonnaise - Canola - 16 Oz - Case Of 12

    Spectrum Naturals
    Only 4 left!

    Spectrum naturals canola mayonnaise is made with expeller pressed canola oil. Creamy and delicious, our non-hydrogenated canola mayonnaise contains...

    View full details
    Original price $114.59 - Original price $114.59
    Original price
    $114.59
    $114.59 - $114.59
    Current price $114.59
  • Original price $34.45 - Original price $34.45
    Original price
    $34.45
    $34.45 - $34.45
    Current price $34.45

    Silver Spring Sauce - Horsradish - Case Of 9 - 9.25 Fl Oz

    Silver Spring
    Only 11 left!

    Horseradish sauce, sassycountry of origin : united statessize : 9.25 fzpack of : 9selling unit : case

    Original price $34.45 - Original price $34.45
    Original price
    $34.45
    $34.45 - $34.45
    Current price $34.45
  • Original price $105.19 - Original price $105.19
    Original price
    $105.19
    $105.19 - $105.19
    Current price $105.19

    Krinos Sesame Seeds - Case Of 12 - 1 Lb.

    Krinos
    116 in stock

    Ground sesame seeds. No trans fat. No cholesterol. Krinos tahini is a thick paste made from raw roasted ground sesame seeds. High in protein and ot...

    View full details
    Original price $105.19 - Original price $105.19
    Original price
    $105.19
    $105.19 - $105.19
    Current price $105.19
  • Original price $149.01 - Original price $149.01
    Original price
    $149.01
    $149.01 - $149.01
    Current price $149.01

    Woodstock Unsalted Organic Sesame Tahini - Case Of 12 - 16 Oz

    Woodstock
    Only 19 left!

    Tahini is the paste made from hulled sesame seeds and is a key ingredient in middle eastern cooking. Our organic tahini is delicious in your favori...

    View full details
    Original price $149.01 - Original price $149.01
    Original price
    $149.01
    $149.01 - $149.01
    Current price $149.01
  • Original price $220.63 - Original price $220.63
    Original price
    $220.63
    $220.63 - $220.63
    Current price $220.63

    Spectrum Naturals Canola Mayonnaise - Case Of 4 - 1 Gal

    Spectrum Naturals
    Only 16 left!

    Spectrum mayonnaise canola is a non-gmo, gluten-free mayonnaise that does not contain hydrogenated oils. Each 1 gal. Container is made with expelle...

    View full details
    Original price $220.63 - Original price $220.63
    Original price
    $220.63
    $220.63 - $220.63
    Current price $220.63
  • Original price $88.83 - Original price $88.83
    Original price
    $88.83
    $88.83 - $88.83
    Current price $88.83

    Haddar Tahini Sesame Paste - Case Of 12 - 15.9 Oz

    Haddar
    Only 15 left!

    Certified gluten free. No preservatives. Naturallybetterwithyouinmind.com. Naturally better with you in mind.com. Product of e.israel.country of or...

    View full details
    Original price $88.83 - Original price $88.83
    Original price
    $88.83
    $88.83 - $88.83
    Current price $88.83
  • Original price $42.04 - Original price $42.04
    Original price
    $42.04
    $42.04 - $42.04
    Current price $42.04

    Beano's Submarine Dressing - Original - Case Of 12 - 8 Oz.

    Beano's
    483 in stock

    This is the original family recipe. 100 percent pure soybean oil and real red wine vinegar are combined with the freshest italian spices available....

    View full details
    Original price $42.04 - Original price $42.04
    Original price
    $42.04
    $42.04 - $42.04
    Current price $42.04
  • Original price $34.45 - Original price $34.45
    Original price
    $34.45
    $34.45 - $34.45
    Current price $34.45

    Bookbinder's - Horseradish - Prepared - Case Of 9 - 9.75 Oz.

    Bookbinder's
    Only 17 left!

    Restaurant style. The old original. Established 1865. Www.bookbindersfoods.com.country of origin : united statessize : 9.75 ozpack of : 9selling ...

    View full details
    Original price $34.45 - Original price $34.45
    Original price
    $34.45
    $34.45 - $34.45
    Current price $34.45
  • Original price $131.11 - Original price $131.11
    Original price
    $131.11
    $131.11 - $131.11
    Current price $131.11

    Spectrum Naturals Organic Olive Oil Mayonnaise - Case Of 12 - 12 Oz.

    Spectrum Naturals
    Only 12 left!

    Spectrum naturals organic olive oil mayonnaise is made with first cold pressed extra virgin olive oil. Cage- free and non-gmo, our mayonnaise is a ...

    View full details
    Original price $131.11 - Original price $131.11
    Original price
    $131.11
    $131.11 - $131.11
    Current price $131.11
  • Original price $62.07 - Original price $62.07
    Original price
    $62.07
    $62.07 - $62.07
    Current price $62.07

    Ziyad Brand Tahini - Sesame Paste - Case Of 6 - 16 Oz.

    Ziyad
    55 in stock

    Ziyad tahini sesame paste is a premium quality mediterranean food. Our tahini paste is made with the single ingredient of hulled sesame seeds. Each...

    View full details
    Original price $62.07 - Original price $62.07
    Original price
    $62.07
    $62.07 - $62.07
    Current price $62.07
  • Original price $114.59 - Original price $114.59
    Original price
    $114.59
    $114.59 - $114.59
    Current price $114.59

    Spectrum Naturals Organic Mayonnaise With Cage Free Eggs - Case Of 12 - 16 Oz.

    Spectrum Naturals
    Only 14 left!

    Spectrum naturals organic mayonnaise is made the old-fashioned way with organic ingredients to elevate the status of any sandwich or salad to organ...

    View full details
    Original price $114.59 - Original price $114.59
    Original price
    $114.59
    $114.59 - $114.59
    Current price $114.59
  • Original price $228.80 - Original price $228.80
    Original price
    $228.80
    $228.80 - $228.80
    Current price $228.80

    Spectrum Naturals Organic Mayonnaise With Cage Free Eggs - Case Of 12 - 32 Oz.

    Spectrum Naturals
    Out of stock

    Spectrum naturals organic mayonnaise is made the old-fashioned way with organic ingredients to elevate the status of any sandwich or salad to organ...

    View full details
    Original price $228.80 - Original price $228.80
    Original price
    $228.80
    $228.80 - $228.80
    Current price $228.80
    Sold out
  • Original price $28.95 - Original price $28.95
    Original price
    $28.95
    $28.95 - $28.95
    Current price $28.95

    Bookbinder's - Tartar Sauce - Traditional - Case Of 9 - 9.5 Oz.

    Bookbinder's
    51 in stock

    Bookbinders traditional tartar sauce is our classic, restaurant style tartar sauce in a 9.5 oz. Bottle. Enjoy the creamy goodness of this authentic...

    View full details
    Original price $28.95 - Original price $28.95
    Original price
    $28.95
    $28.95 - $28.95
    Current price $28.95
  • Original price $29.53 - Original price $29.53
    Original price
    $29.53
    $29.53 - $29.53
    Current price $29.53

    Inglehoffer - Cream Style Horseradish - Case Of 6 - 9.5 Oz.

    Inglehoffer
    59 in stock

    Inglehoffer cream style horseradish is americaโ€™s first non refrigerated cream style horseradish. Made from 100 percent fresh grated horseradish roo...

    View full details
    Original price $29.53 - Original price $29.53
    Original price
    $29.53
    $29.53 - $29.53
    Current price $29.53
  • Original price $75.06 - Original price $75.06
    Original price
    $75.06
    $75.06 - $75.06
    Current price $75.06

    Woodstock Organic Mayonnaise - Case Of 12 - 16 Oz

    Woodstock
    107 in stock

    Woodstock organic mayonnaise is made with the best ingredients including cage-free eggs and expeller pressed soybean oil and contains absolutely n...

    View full details
    Original price $75.06 - Original price $75.06
    Original price
    $75.06
    $75.06 - $75.06
    Current price $75.06
  • Original price $139.14 - Original price $139.14
    Original price $139.14
    $141.79
    $141.79 - $141.79
    Current price $141.79

    Sir Kensington's Classic Mayonnaise - Case Of 6 - 32 Fl Oz.

    Sir Kensington's
    Only 18 left!

    Sir kensington's classic mayonnaise made with sunflower oil is certified humane, certified gluten-free, kosher, and non-gmo project verified. Our m...

    View full details
    Original price $139.14 - Original price $139.14
    Original price $139.14
    $141.79
    $141.79 - $141.79
    Current price $141.79
  • Original price $147.72 - Original price $147.72
    Original price
    $147.72
    $147.72 - $147.72
    Current price $147.72

    East Wind 100% Roasted Sesame No Salt Tahini - 15 Lb.

    East Wind
    21 in stock

    Nut butters. This wholesome organic tahini is made by the workers of cooperatively run east wind nut butters in the lovely ozark hills of rural sou...

    View full details
    Original price $147.72 - Original price $147.72
    Original price
    $147.72
    $147.72 - $147.72
    Current price $147.72
  • Original price $190.45 - Original price $190.45
    Original price
    $190.45
    $190.45 - $190.45
    Current price $190.45

    Spectrum Naturals Canola Mayonnaise - Single Bulk Item - 30lb

    Spectrum Naturals
    Only 18 left!

    New look! partners in cooking. Culinary. For spreads & dressings. With omega-3 & a zesty taste. Made with spectrum expeller pressed oil.cou...

    View full details
    Original price $190.45 - Original price $190.45
    Original price
    $190.45
    $190.45 - $190.45
    Current price $190.45
  • Original price $26.48 - Original price $26.48
    Original price
    $26.48
    $26.48 - $26.48
    Current price $26.48

    Mayo Gourmet Roasted Chipotle Mayonnaise - Case Of 6 - 11 Oz.

    Mayo Gourmet
    Only 9 left!

    Since 1905. Delicious as a spread, dip, or in recipes. Made in usa.country of origin : united statesis gluten free : yesis kosher : yessize : 11 ...

    View full details
    Original price $26.48 - Original price $26.48
    Original price
    $26.48
    $26.48 - $26.48
    Current price $26.48
  • Original price $81.22 - Original price $81.22
    Original price
    $81.22
    $81.22 - $81.22
    Current price $81.22

    Hellman's Organic Mayonnaise - Case Of 6 - 15 Fz

    Hellmann's
    Only 13 left!

    Hellman's organic mayonnaise is a creamy condiment made from cage-free eggs, soybean oil, vinegar and a dash of lemon juice concentrate for citrusy...

    View full details
    Original price $81.22 - Original price $81.22
    Original price
    $81.22
    $81.22 - $81.22
    Current price $81.22
  • Original price $64.74
    Original price $64.74 - Original price $64.74
    Original price $64.74
    Current price $59.98
    $59.98 - $59.98
    Current price $59.98

    Chosen Foods - Coconut Oil Mayo - Case Of 6 - 12 Fl Oz.

    Chosen Foods
    Out of stock

    Chosen foods traditional coconut oil mayo is a blend of pure coconut oil with cage free-eggs to create a rich and creamy mayo. We use real ingredie...

    View full details
    Original price $64.74
    Original price $64.74 - Original price $64.74
    Original price $64.74
    Current price $59.98
    $59.98 - $59.98
    Current price $59.98
    Sold out
  • Original price $96.36 - Original price $96.36
    Original price
    $96.36
    $96.36 - $96.36
    Current price $96.36

    Once Again Sesame Tahini Organic - Single Bulk Item - 9lb

    Once Again
    Only 11 left!

    Once again sesame tahini organic - single bulk item - 9lbcountry of origin : united statesis gluten free : yesis gmo free : yesis kosher : yesis v...

    View full details
    Original price $96.36 - Original price $96.36
    Original price
    $96.36
    $96.36 - $96.36
    Current price $96.36
  • Original price $64.74
    Original price $64.74 - Original price $64.74
    Original price $64.74
    Current price $60.04
    $60.04 - $60.04
    Current price $60.04

    Chosen Foods - Avocado Oil Vegan Mayo - Case Of 6 - 12 Oz.

    Chosen Foods
    489 in stock

    Chosen foods avocado oil vegan mayo is crafted with non-gmo and certified vegan ingredients. Each serving contains zero trans fat and just 90 calor...

    View full details
    Original price $64.74
    Original price $64.74 - Original price $64.74
    Original price $64.74
    Current price $60.04
    $60.04 - $60.04
    Current price $60.04
    Save 7% Save %
  • Original price $85.14
    Original price $85.14 - Original price $85.14
    Original price $85.14
    Current price $74.79
    $74.79 - $74.79
    Current price $74.79

    Primal Kitchen Mayo - Avocado Oil - Case Of 6 - 12 Fl Oz.

    Primal Kitchen
    24 in stock

    Primal kitchen mayo - avocado oil - case of 6 - 12 fl oz.country of origin : united statesis gluten free : yesis gmo free : yesis kosher : yessize...

    View full details
    Original price $85.14
    Original price $85.14 - Original price $85.14
    Original price $85.14
    Current price $74.79
    $74.79 - $74.79
    Current price $74.79
    Save 12% Save %
  • Original price $57.09 - Original price $57.09
    Original price
    $57.09
    $57.09 - $57.09
    Current price $57.09

    Reese Horseradish - Prepared - Case Of 12 - 6.5 Oz

    Reese
    34 in stock

    Reese horseradish, prepared is a natural and delicious addition to a variety of dishes. Made primarily with natural ingredients, this sauce is larg...

    View full details
    Original price $57.09 - Original price $57.09
    Original price
    $57.09
    $57.09 - $57.09
    Current price $57.09
  • Original price $37.93 - Original price $37.93
    Original price
    $37.93
    $37.93 - $37.93
    Current price $37.93

    Kewpie Squeeze Tube Mayonnaise - Case Of 6 - 12 Oz

    Kewpie
    55 in stock

    Kewpie squeeze tube mayonnaise is a rich and creamy egg yolk mayonnaise with a famously distinct vinegar flavor. Our mayonnaise blends perfectly wi...

    View full details
    Original price $37.93 - Original price $37.93
    Original price
    $37.93
    $37.93 - $37.93
    Current price $37.93
  • Original price $85.14
    Original price $85.14 - Original price $85.14
    Original price $85.14
    Current price $74.79
    $74.79 - $74.79
    Current price $74.79

    Primal Kitchen Chipotle Lime Mayo - Avocado Oil - Case Of 6 - 12 Oz.

    Primal Kitchen
    125 in stock

    Primal kitchen chipotle lime mayo - avocado oil - case of 6 - 12 oz.country of origin : united statesis dairy free : yesis gluten free : yesis gmo...

    View full details
    Original price $85.14
    Original price $85.14 - Original price $85.14
    Original price $85.14
    Current price $74.79
    $74.79 - $74.79
    Current price $74.79
    Save 12% Save %
  • Original price $25.14 - Original price $25.14
    Original price
    $25.14
    $25.14 - $25.14
    Current price $25.14

    Woeber's Sandwich Pal Smoky Horseradish Sauce - Case Of 6 - 16 Fl Oz.

    Woeber's
    Out of stock

    Since 1905. Tradition of excellence for over 100 years. Comments? questions? call toll free 1-800-548-2929. Www.woebermustard.com.country of origin...

    View full details
    Original price $25.14 - Original price $25.14
    Original price
    $25.14
    $25.14 - $25.14
    Current price $25.14
    Sold out
  • Original price $80.70
    Original price $80.70 - Original price $80.70
    Original price $80.70
    Current price $73.13
    $73.13 - $73.13
    Current price $73.13

    Artisana Butter - Raw Tahini - Case Of 6 - 14 Oz.

    Artisana
    85 in stock

    Our artisana organics raw tahini sesame seed butter starts with the choicest organic raw premium sesame seeds and adds - absolutely nothing. It has...

    View full details
    Original price $80.70
    Original price $80.70 - Original price $80.70
    Original price $80.70
    Current price $73.13
    $73.13 - $73.13
    Current price $73.13
    Save 9% Save %
  • Original price $34.45 - Original price $34.45
    Original price
    $34.45
    $34.45 - $34.45
    Current price $34.45

    Inglehoffer - Cream Style Horseradish - Case Of 12 - 3.75 Oz.

    Inglehoffer
    Only 3 left!

    Inglehoffer cream style horseradish is americaโ€™s first non refrigerated cream style horseradish. Made from 100 percent fresh grated horseradish roo...

    View full details
    Original price $34.45 - Original price $34.45
    Original price
    $34.45
    $34.45 - $34.45
    Current price $34.45
  • Original price $105.96 - Original price $105.96
    Original price
    $105.96
    $105.96 - $105.96
    Current price $105.96

    Joyva - Roasted Sesame Tahini - 15 Oz - Case Of 12

    Joyva
    45 in stock

    Joyva roasted sesame tahini is an all-natural creamy puree of sesame seeds that has a light nut-like flavor. Each 15 oz. Container provides 15 serv...

    View full details
    Original price $105.96 - Original price $105.96
    Original price
    $105.96
    $105.96 - $105.96
    Current price $105.96
  • Original price $42.94 - Original price $42.94
    Original price
    $42.94
    $42.94 - $42.94
    Current price $42.94

    Louisiana Tartar Sauce - Case Of 12 - 10.5 Oz

    Louisiana Fish Fry
    27 in stock

    Louisiana tartar sauce is made with real relish, onion and lemon for a zesty zing when you use it with fried fish or other seafood. When you use th...

    View full details
    Original price $42.94 - Original price $42.94
    Original price
    $42.94
    $42.94 - $42.94
    Current price $42.94
  • Original price $25.14 - Original price $25.14
    Original price
    $25.14
    $25.14 - $25.14
    Current price $25.14

    Woeber's Sauce - Horseredish - Case Of 6 - 16 Oz.

    Woeber's
    167 in stock

    Woeber's sandwich pal horseradish sauce is a flavored sandwich sauce made with fresh ground horseradish. Our certified kosher sauce contains only 2...

    View full details
    Original price $25.14 - Original price $25.14
    Original price
    $25.14
    $25.14 - $25.14
    Current price $25.14
  • Original price $64.74
    Original price $64.74 - Original price $64.74
    Original price $64.74
    Current price $60.04
    $60.04 - $60.04
    Current price $60.04

    Chosen Foods Avocado Oil - Mayo - Case Of 6 - 12 Oz.

    Chosen Foods
    120 in stock

    Chosen foods 100% pure avocado oil mayo is a blend of our fan-favorite avocado oil with cage free-eggs and a touch of honey to create a rich and cr...

    View full details
    Original price $64.74
    Original price $64.74 - Original price $64.74
    Original price $64.74
    Current price $60.04
    $60.04 - $60.04
    Current price $60.04
    Save 7% Save %
  • Original price $66.23 - Original price $66.23
    Original price
    $66.23
    $66.23 - $66.23
    Current price $66.23

    Woodstock Organic Mayo - Case Of 12 - 11.25 Oz

    Woodstock
    77 in stock

    Woodstock organic mayonnaise is made with the best ingredients including cage-free eggs and expeller pressed soybean oil and contains absolutely n...

    View full details
    Original price $66.23 - Original price $66.23
    Original price
    $66.23
    $66.23 - $66.23
    Current price $66.23
  • Original price $41.88 - Original price $41.88
    Original price
    $41.88
    $41.88 - $41.88
    Current price $41.88

    Lee Kum Kee Mayonnaise - Sriracha - Case Of 6 - 15 Fl Oz

    Lee Kum Kee
    361 in stock

    Gluten free. Gluten free certification program. Beyond celiac. Www.gf.cert.org. Hong kong. Great for: dips; salad dressings; sauces; marinades; sti...

    View full details
    Original price $41.88 - Original price $41.88
    Original price
    $41.88
    $41.88 - $41.88
    Current price $41.88

Compare products

{"one"=>"Select 2 or 3 items to compare", "other"=>"{{ count }} of 3 items selected"}

Select first item to compare

Select second item to compare

Select third item to compare

Compare